Ask a Football Official anything

514 Questions

Last Answer on January 23, 2021

If it is an unbalanced formation and the offense wants to throw to the OT on the end of the LOS. Does the throw have to be backwards or just behind the LOS?

Asked by Tate over 10 years ago

In high school and college, a pass would have to be backwards to be legal. Behind the LOS isn't a factor there. A forward pass to an originally ineligible player (by position or number) is illegal.

In the NFL, the rules are more restrictive. To be eligible to receive a forward pass, an ineligible (lineman's number - between 50 and 79) player must report in to the referee and be announced. In that case, the player can receive a forward pass.

Any backward pass can be caught legally by anyone - that's why those end of game multiple "laterals" are legal.

963 Votes

Can multiple players wear the same number as long as they are not on the field at the same time and as long as they play within the jersey number allowed for that position. In other words can an offense have two #80 WRs that would rotate in and out

Asked by Bravovictor about 12 years ago

You had a yes answer until you threw in that last line. I'm going to deal with NCAA rules. Rule 1-4-2-e reads: Two players playing the same position may not wear the same number during the game. [Italics added] The obvious reason is deception and unsportsmanlike activity. You could, in theory, have a #80 playing WR and also have an 80 at defensive end. To take it one step further, if you do have two 80's, for example, they cannot be in the gane at the same time.

957 Votes

When a QB is behind the line of scrimmage, when is it considered a sack to a minus rushing attempt?

Asked by Turk over 11 years ago

That's a statistical issue, which officials don't really deal with. My personal understanding is that sacks are rushing attempts.

953 Votes

In a TX high school game, the kicker missed the ball when he was attempting to kick off. Kind of a "Charlie Brown" moment...lol. Anyway, the ref's acted like it didn't even happen and rekicked it. Shouldn't it have been an offside penalty?

Asked by Ray's dad over 11 years ago

No. Although I undrstand your idea. On a kickoff, only the kicker may (technically) be in front of the restrainig line. Especially with "soccer sdtyle" kickers, they often approach from the side. In this case, the generally accepted practice is to pretty much call a do over, which is what they did. No kick, no play.

953 Votes

Also on Jobstr...

Border Patrol Agent

Do Mexican authorities help on THEIR side of the border?

Football Official

Do you think it's ok for NFL refs to play fantasy football?

Birthday Party Clown

What's the meanest thing a kid ever said to you during a party?

Why are players penalized for excessive celebration when they score a touchdown, but Green Bay players can actually LEAVE the playing field, join the spectators in the stands, and that is not only acceptable, but cutely named the Lambeau Leap?

Asked by James over 10 years ago

Good question. I don't have the NFL rule. But using college as a guide, you can't draw excessive attention to yourself (e.g. a choreographed dance, or taking a marker from the goalpost padding and "signing" the ball). My best guess is that the Lambeau Leap pre-dated the rulings about excessive celebration and it is more a sharing/bonding moment with the fans than highlighting the player. If I'm not mistaken, other players have interacted with fans without a penalty.

952 Votes

Can you have a padded structure that shelters your players like an above ground dugout in Men's football not soccer as long as it is far enough away from playing surface.

Asked by Bravovictor about 12 years ago

First thought: why? You have heated benches and, believe me. it's hard enough leaving them to go on the field if it's cold. There is nothing in the NCAA rule book prohibiting it. But I'm imagining Bud Grant, the old-time coach of the Vikings, spinning in his grave. When the Vikings played outdoors, he didn't allow heated benches. Dugouts or soccer type enclosures? It just ain't football.

951 Votes

Suppose STL-SEA game is tied 17-17. In OT, STL receives ball and kicks FG. SEA returns kickoff to STL 10. SEA throws interception to STL defender at the 2, who backtracks and is tackled for safety. OT safety ends game, so does SEA win 19-20?!

Asked by John A. over 12 years ago

I can't answer definitively for the NFL, but in college the answer would be no. In college there is a momentum rule (and a fellow official says he's pretty sure it exists in the NFL, too). It's to prevenrt cheap safeties on good efensive plays like the one you describe. Inside the five, if a player intercepts or receives a punt, then goes into the end zone where he is downed, the ball would come out to the spot of the interception/kick reception. That's why you see officials toss a bean bag at that spot. It would be the defense's ball - in this case Seattle - 1/10 at the 2.

950 Votes

Showing 85 - 91

Show All

310 More Answers by Football Official

Last 7

10 11 12 13 14 15

...

Next 7 Answers

Football Official

Ask me anything!

What do YOU do?

If it is an unbalanced formation and the offense wants to throw to the OT on the end of the LOS. Does the throw have to be backwards or just behind the LOS?

Can multiple players wear the same number as long as they are not on the field at the same time and as long as they play within the jersey number allowed for that position. In other words can an offense have two #80 WRs that would rotate in and out

When a QB is behind the line of scrimmage, when is it considered a sack to a minus rushing attempt?

In a TX high school game, the kicker missed the ball when he was attempting to kick off. Kind of a "Charlie Brown" moment...lol. Anyway, the ref's acted like it didn't even happen and rekicked it. Shouldn't it have been an offside penalty?

Also on Jobstr...

Why are players penalized for excessive celebration when they score a touchdown, but Green Bay players can actually LEAVE the playing field, join the spectators in the stands, and that is not only acceptable, but cutely named the Lambeau Leap?

Can you have a padded structure that shelters your players like an above ground dugout in Men's football not soccer as long as it is far enough away from playing surface.

Suppose STL-SEA game is tied 17-17. In OT, STL receives ball and kicks FG. SEA returns kickoff to STL 10. SEA throws interception to STL defender at the 2, who backtracks and is tackled for safety. OT safety ends game, so does SEA win 19-20?!

Football Official

Ask me anything!

What do YOU do?

If it is an unbalanced formation and the offense wants to throw to the OT on the end of the LOS. Does the throw have to be backwards or just behind the LOS?

Can multiple players wear the same number as long as they are not on the field at the same time and as long as they play within the jersey number allowed for that position. In other words can an offense have two #80 WRs that would rotate in and out

When a QB is behind the line of scrimmage, when is it considered a sack to a minus rushing attempt?

In a TX high school game, the kicker missed the ball when he was attempting to kick off. Kind of a "Charlie Brown" moment...lol. Anyway, the ref's acted like it didn't even happen and rekicked it. Shouldn't it have been an offside penalty?

Also on Jobstr...

Why are players penalized for excessive celebration when they score a touchdown, but Green Bay players can actually LEAVE the playing field, join the spectators in the stands, and that is not only acceptable, but cutely named the Lambeau Leap?

Can you have a padded structure that shelters your players like an above ground dugout in Men's football not soccer as long as it is far enough away from playing surface.

Suppose STL-SEA game is tied 17-17. In OT, STL receives ball and kicks FG. SEA returns kickoff to STL 10. SEA throws interception to STL defender at the 2, who backtracks and is tackled for safety. OT safety ends game, so does SEA win 19-20?!

Login

Forgot Your Password?

Register